SigPhiSigPhi

There is No Communism in Russia

Emma Goldman

Language:
English
Status:
Complete work
Authorship:
Written by the author
Condition of the text:
No scanning noise detected (automatic measure over the whole text, not checked by hand)
Extent:
~6,110 words · 29 passages
Cite this work
  • APAEmma Goldman. (n.d.). There is No Communism in Russia. Digital reproduction: SigPhi. https://sigphiai.com/en/works/emma-goldman/there-is-no-communism-in-russia
  • MLAEmma Goldman. There is No Communism in Russia. Digital reproduction, SigPhi, https://sigphiai.com/en/works/emma-goldman/there-is-no-communism-in-russia.
  • ChicagoEmma Goldman. There is No Communism in Russia. Digital reproduction, SigPhi. https://sigphiai.com/en/works/emma-goldman/there-is-no-communism-in-russia.

Reference to the edition that SigPhi reproduces: SigPhi is its digital reproduction, not its publisher. The edition's year is not in the metadata (hence "n.d."), and the translator appears only when recorded.

What it is about

From 1935: Stalin's USSR is not communism but state capitalism, said by an anarchist who had lived there.

Context and history

It continues the argument of My Disillusionment fifteen years on, with Stalin now in power. The state-capitalism thesis would have a long career in every later critical left. This is a short article, not a book: its size in the catalogue is no defect of the copy. Much of Goldman's work took this form, in her magazine Mother Earth and in pamphlets.

Editorial context, not a citable source: unlike the passages of the work itself, these statements cannot be checked against the corpus.

How it begins
There are more classes in Soviet Russia today than in 1917, more than in most other countries in the world. The Bolsheviki have created a vast Soviet bureaucracy, enjoying special privileges and almost unlimited authority over the masses, industrial and agricultural. Above that bureaucracy is the still more privileged class of responsible comrades, the new Soviet aristocracy. The industrial class is divided and subdivided into numerous gradations. There are the _udarniki_, the shock troops of labor, entitled to various privileges; the specialists, the artisans, the ordinary workers and laborers. There are the factory cells, the shop committees, the pioneers, the _komsomoltsi_, the party members, all enjoying material advantages and authority. There is the large class of _lishentsi_, persons deprived of civil rights, the greater number of them also of chance to work, of the right to live in certain places, practically cut off from all means of existence. The notorious pale of the Czarist times, which forbade Jews to live in certain parts of the country, has been revived for the entire population by the introduction of the new Soviet passport system. Over and above all these classes is the dreaded G.P.U., secret, powerful and arbitrary, a government within the government. The G.P.U., in its turn, has its own class divisions. It has its own armed forces, its own commercial and industrial establishments, its own laws and regulations, and a vast slave army of convict labor. Aye, even in the Soviet prisons and concentration camps there are various classes with special privileges.

Read the full work →

← Back to Emma Goldman